Murder charge and Criminal Gang Enhancement


Jefferson County, Indiana (March 16, 2023) – A motorcycle gang leader convicted on murder and related felony charges was sentenced Wednesday to a total of 120 years in prison by Jefferson Circuit Court Judge D.J. Mote.

Michael J. “Billy Goat” Karnuth was sentenced to 60 years on the murder charge and an additional 60 years on the criminal gang enhancement. “This is a significant sentence which all but ensures a dangerous man will no longer be a threat to our community” said Prosecutor David Sutter.

In June 2021, Dustin B. “Kutter” Lindner, 35, Georgetown, Ky., died from a gunshot wound to the chest during a shootout. Lindner, a member of the Pagans motorcycle gang, was with Karnuth and members of another gang, the Warlocks.

They were confronting Shaun Rudis, whom they believed was displaying patches and tattoos of the motorcycle gangs while not being a member. Karnuth was president of the Heavy Hitters chapter of the Warlocks and had spent weeks gathering information on Rudis’ whereabouts and organizing the pursuit of Rudis.

Following the shooting, gang members fled the area in two vehicles but crashed into each other. They attempted to dispose of a vehicle, firearms, and gang paraphernalia following the shooting, but those items were ultimately recovered by law enforcement.

Sutter further stated, “The conviction and sentence are the direct results of the outstanding investigation conducted by the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office and the Indiana State Police.

More from Local News


Local News

No Serious Injuries in Fiery Ripley County Crash

The two-vehicle crash took place on Tuesday.

Indiana DNR: Make Water Safety a Priority

With Memorial Day weekend here, Hoosiers are reminded to make water safety a priority now and throughout the summer.

Kentucky Governor Announces More Awards as State Builds Out Electric Vehicle Charging Network

Private developers will design, build, operate and maintain 42 ‘fast chargers’ for public use

Local Sports

Southwestern Baseball Four-Peats, Leads ORVC All-Conf. Team with Four Selections

Seventeen players were named to the 2024 ORVC Baseball All-Conference Team.

Local Sports for May 20-21, 2024

Any missing scores or to report a score email

Two-Time State Champ to Take Over Greensburg Boys Basketball Program

There will be a new face patrolling the sideline in the EIAC this winter.